As I explained a few years ago, automating new lines and even existing lines would have many advantages. Even Sound Transit has recently considered automating the Ballard extension. Some people still consider automated train control (ATC) as unproven even though many airports (SeaTac, JFK AirTrain…) and subways use this technology such as Vancouver Skytrain and new lines on Hawaii and in Montreal already use the technology. Let’s look at the history.
Automating trains is much easier than having fully autonomous cars. As long as the trains run on tracks in a separate right of way, no complex video or even lidar systems are required but track sensors and a more powerful signaling and train control system. Platform doors are often added for additional safety.
Boston already started to experiment with automating trains in 1901. Berlin in 1928. Paris operated a short line from 1952 to 1957 but didn’t have funds for upgrades until the first main line was upgraded in 1966. More lines have been upgraded since. Tokyo started limited operation in 1962, more lines have been added since. Hitachi automated the Disney and Linimo monorail. London started tests in 1968. The Victoria Underground Line finally started fully automated operations in 1967.
While initially the trains still had a driver, fully driverless operation started in Kobe (Japan) and later in Lille (France), Barcelona and airports such as JFK.
In Nürnberg (Germany) they even allowed mixed operation between traditional and driverless trains in 2008.
More modern light metros such as Vancouver’s Skytrain (in 1985), London’s Dockland Light Railway (in 1987) and Copenhagen were designed as automated systems from the beginning allowing for shorter trains without a cab, smaller stations, and higher frequency. Recent new lines in Montreal (REM) and Hawaii also leveraged these advantages. Now many systems around the world are driverless. While Italian Ansaldo/Hitachi Rail STS developed their train systems around ATC, established rail provides (Alstom Urbalis Fluence and Siemens Trainguard MT) added ATC support to some of their existing rail offerings. Siemens AutomatedTrain effort is even automating regular heavy rail operation including the video detection of obstacles along the tracks.
As I explained in my prior post, Sound Transit had evaluated various modes in 2014. This included automated light metro systems such as Skytrain. At that time they decided on light rail technology for the spine to allow for both DSTT as well as at-grade operation. However, for some extensions Sound Transit is now planning, such as Ballard, it might be better to keep them separate rather than interlining them to leverage ATC advantages such as higher frequency and smaller stations.
As the northern Link line is fully grade separated, Link trains could even run fully automated from Everett to downtown. This would allow more precise acceleration and breaking, reduced headways (as close as 60sec) and faster turnaround at the end of the line, reducing the need for pocket tracks. Alstrom claims it reduces trackside equipment usage by up to 20% and energy consumption by up to 30%.
I hope Sound Transit would seriously consider automation where feasible.